The stock market is down a stunning 40% in just over four months. (Chart) Now suddenly investment leverage is working in reverse and the Smith Manoeuvre is a little scarier to some people.
We’re not investment advisors so we can’t comment on whether now’s a good time to jump into this strategy. But we’re hearing a lot of stories from people employing the Smith Manoeuvre who aren’t too happy with their returns as of late. They’re also not happy about owing more on their line of credit than their portfolios are worth.
This is just a friendly piece of advice to mortgage brokers everywhere. Most of us are not financial planners. Unless you’re licensed to provide investment advice be very very careful what you tell clients. The Smith Manoeuvre is a long-term strategy that is sometimes subject to short-term pain. When clients experience pain they look to “offload” it. Who better to take this brunt than all the advisors who got them into the strategy in the first place.
For our clients we handle solely the readvanceable mortgage piece. We leave all the investment strategy part to the financial pro’s, who are better equipped to judge suitability. We work with several advisors closely, but we always stay in our niche. This approach is in both the client’s best interest (they get better overall advice) and the broker’s.
http://www.yourhome.ca/homes/article/519655
can someone please explain what is readvanceable mortgage and which banks offer it?
Hi Reb,
Here are a few links that will help:
Smith Manoeuvre
Smith Manoeuvre Mortgages
Cheers,
Rob
I never been a fan of this move. By the way–is it even 100% legal to do–there is some speculation about that with Revenue Canada, do your research.
As far as I know, it is 100% legal. After all, in theory, you’re borrowing money to make more money. But leveraging is also very dangerous, I am sure a lot of people just dig themselves quite a big hole. However, looking from another side, it is probably a good strategy to look into now if you willing to risk and you haven’t start :)
Hello MT,
The key thing for the SM is:
1. Be comfortable with the ups and downs of the markets.
2. Be in a high tax bracket.
3. Use tax refunds to pay down the mortgage.
4. Do not be afraid to have funds that have cash and bonds
5. Make sure you have enough insurance for disability and life to cover debts, etc.
6. Look at your RRSPs do they have stocks bonds and cash? If you only have GICs … stay away from the SM.
7. Do you have a good job? If you lost it next week could you get another one…for the same pay? The markets may be down, but no paycheck is worse.
Hope this helps a bit.
Brian