The average Canadian’s debt-to-income ratio is now 145%—an all-time high (largely due to greater mortgage costs).
Home prices are now five times the average persons’ after-tax income (the long-term average has been 3x).
The above are taken from this Vanier Institute report.
The report also said mortgage arrears are up 50% year-over-year. Some of the media has picked up on this, suggesting that defaults are soaring.
Not exactly.
The arrears statistics Vanier quotes have been out for a while. October arrears (upon which Vanier’s findings are based) were announced a few months ago, so this isn’t the breaking news some have made it out to be.
More importantly, while a 50% arrears increase may sound large (it’s actually 44% based on the latest data), the absolute number of arrears is still ultra-low by international standards.
Less than 5 out of 1,000 Canadian mortgagors is in arrears (i.e., late on payments by 90 days or more).
Compared to a year ago, 5,699 more borrowers were in arrears (based on the October 2009 data used in the report).
On the other hand, there were 91,986 more mortgages in that same one-year time period.
In all, Canadian Bankers Association (CBA) data includes almost four million mortgages in total.
So again, on an absolute basis, arrears have not been abnormally high, and Canada does not have an arrears problem.
As for a consumer debt problem, well, that’s another matter.
______________________________________________________
Sidebar: The CBA is the most quoted source of arrears data in Canada, and the source used in Vanier’s report. This data is from the biggest lenders only and includes most, but not all, Canadian arrears.
Last modified: April 28, 2014
Well put!
I have a general question to the posters of this site (and will not state my CMHC opinions to avoid the rath):
Does anyone know if HELOCs and similar loans are considered as “consumer debt” or “mortgage debt” in these types of reports?
With all of the data points coming out on the high Canadian debt levels, I’ve been wondering if at least some of the growth is due to the popularity of these loans.
thanks.
Here in Alberta we just posted the highest arrears level since ’97
http://edmontonhousingbust.com/2010/02/december-mortgage-arrears/
Still just 0.75%, but a record nonetheless.
Thank you for the report, CMT. I find CBA provides timely stats on all class’s of debt delinquencies as well as breakdown by province. Saves getting caught up in media hoopla and allows a person to draw their own perspectives.
http://cba.ca/index.php?option=com_content&view=publication&id=69&Itemid=56&lang=en
Thanks for posting the link Banker.
Cheers,
Rob
Hi T.O.
Unsecured credit lines are usually considered consumer debt while secured LOCs (HELOCs) are typically viewed as mortgage debt.
Vanier combines debt from both sources to calculate their debt-to-income ratio.
Cheers,
Rob
thanks Rob – I guess that means if consumer debt is growing at a fast rate, that’s definitely a bad thing…
But – if mortgage debt is growing at a fast rate, the stats need to be separated into “mortgage leverage” vs. “mortgage debt” to know how bad it is.