Written by 2:58 PM Mortgage Strategies • 23 Comments Views: 0

A Few Misconceptions

Boomer-and-Echo-Mortgage-Brokers-ArticleMisconceptions occur in every business and the mortgage business is no different.

A recent example is this post by Boomer & Echo (B&E), a prominent blog that we typically enjoy. In it, B&E opines on why not to use a mortgage broker.

In the piece, the author gets some stuff wrong. As often happens, we came across it in our weekly blog scan and feel obliged to offer some counterpoints.

B&E makes four claims. They are:

  1. Brokers push 5-year fixed rates.

    Counterpoint:
    Brokers sell a higher ratio of variable-rate mortgages than bank salespeople, and have for quite some time. That’s per executives we’ve questioned at banks with both broker and retail channels (e.g. CIBC and Scotiabank). In general, however, all mortgage professionals (bank or broker) sell a lot of 5-year fixed product. It’s the most popular term (has been for decades), it’s the easiest to qualify for, and it has the most competitive discounting (albeit, not presently).
  2. Loyalty to your bank pays.Counterpoint:

    The Bank of Canada concluded exactly the opposite (more). To summarize, its research found that existing customers pay more than new customers. What’s more, no one lender continually has the best mortgage options. By comparison shopping, good brokers can save homeowners interest and identify the lender with the right flexibility/value tradeoff. The best brokers provide expert term analysis, proper deal structuring and helpful strategies to reduce a borrower’s amortization.

  3. Bankers have better reputations

    Facts: The RBC specialist incident last April proved that reputation should be judged individually, not by virtue of where a mortgage advisor works. Generally, brokers and bank specialists are both paid by commission and the commission is similar whether they sell a 5-year fixed or variable. Neither is holier that the other in that respect, except that bank reps are hired to push only one brand.
  4. You’re better off doing it yourselfCounterpoint:

    We have visions that people will someday get a mortgage online like they buy a stock at iTrade. But we’re not there yet. Good brokers provide counsel that saves time and money. Do-it-yourselfers sometimes discount the value of advice, mesmerized instead by brokers/bankers who can save them a few basis points in rate. For most, that’s a mistake because:

    • Few individuals grasp the mortgage math needed to perform proper term selection. Term selection impacts borrowing cost far more than rate selection. A “good rate” alone does not equal a “good deal.”
    • There are lots of creative techniques that skilled advisors can use to help people whittle down principal quicker.
    • Lenders rarely disclose all of their mortgage restrictions until you sign their contracts. Brokers know the benefits and pitfalls of multiple lenders, and advise borrowers in advance.

It is possible to pick your own investments, do your own taxes or write your own will, but people still hire financial planners, accountants and lawyers. There’s only so much time in a day and we can’t specialize in everything.

In all of those industries there are great and not-so-great practitioners. Brokers are no different. Interview several before picking one. Ask questions like:

  • Which lenders they use most often and why
  • How long they’ve been in business full-time
  • Why their term recommendation is mathematically sound for your specific needs.

Sense if you can trust them. If they seem to care about you, are competent and make you feel comfortable, you’ll be glad to have them on your side.


Rob McLister, CMT

Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today

Last modified: April 29, 2014

Canada’s preeminent mortgage information resource.

Close